Reviews

TIME magazine on Ian McDonald

Time magazine’s Barbara Ehrenreich recommends Ian McDonald’s River of Godsin the current issue, in a piece entitled, “Alternative Universes, With a Hindi Glossary.”

She says: “I read fiction addictively to get as far out of this flat and blighted ‘real world’ as I can. When a friend recommended Ian McDonald’s River of Gods, I was dubious; 600 pages, including a glossary of Hindi terms? But it worked… There aren’t many literary sci-fi thrillers that deliver a mind-expanding metaphysical punch, and this one ended all too soon. But in the afterglow of McDonald’s lushly blooming imagination, even the real world is looking better.”

TIME magazine on Ian McDonald Read More »

Has It Really Been So Long Since "Who Shot JR" ?

The latest issue of Locus magazine has a review of David Louis Edelman’s just-released MultiReal,chocked full of good and quotable things like:

“As SF, it’s a brilliant imagining of a near-future that not only extrapolates convincingly from current technology and culture but fills in the gaps with world-building so detailed as to verge on the tedious.”

…and….

“Others have imagined a future in which nano-machines have colonized the human body, …but few have done so as convincingly as Edelman does in these books.”

…and…

‘Others have also focused on the business side of SF, …but I’ve never encountered an SF writer whose focus is so relentlessly on the nuts and bolts of the entrepreneurial world, from the boardroom to the factory to the sales office, and who—pontification aside—can make the minutiae of that world seem as exciting and dangerous as a military operation.”

But the reviewer does seem to have tripped up on the idea that because Dave’s character Natch is the protagonist that he is being held up as a laudable individual. As witness:

“I have no doubt that others will be enamored of a novel in which the main character is frequently referred to as ‘the entrepreneur,’ as if there were no higher accolade available, and no one else worthy to bear it. Whenever I came across this descriptor, I simply replaced it with ‘the demigod’ and read on.”

Mind you, I’m not arguing with the review – because it’s always a bad idea to contest someone else’s subjective opinion – and I’m plenty happy with the quotables above. I’m just interested in the notion of protagonist as role model because a few other people came away with similar sentiments from the first book. (I myself worked for someone very much like Natch once upon a time, and so had no trouble recognizing exactly what he was.) But I find myself wondering why we seem to have such a hard time with flawed protagonists in SF. Our sister genre, mystery, is practically built on the adventures of broken human beings you might want on your case but wouldn’t necessarily enjoy having a beer with, loaning money to, or dating.

Anyway, I find this amusing, given that Dave himself just compared Natch to Adolph Hitler here in his post on John Scalzi’s Whatever blog author spotlight, The Big Idea.

Has It Really Been So Long Since "Who Shot JR" ? Read More »

Readers Will Mourn

Publishers Weekly just weighed in on Joe Abercrombie’s forthcoming Last Argument of Kings:

“The sword & sorcery trilogy that began with The Blade Itself (2007) and Before They Are Hanged (2008) comes to a violent, sardonic and brilliant conclusion. … All these people are believable, especially as they dabble in grimly convincing magic and struggle to hear their consciences through the roar of carnage and betrayal. Abercrombie is a fresh new talent, presenting a dark view of life with wit and zest, and readers will mourn the end of this vivid story arc.”

Readers Will Mourn Read More »

MultiReal: A Matrix fans delight!

Over at Grasping at the Wind, John reviews David Louis Edelman’s just-released MultiReal, which he proclaims, “an exciting and excellent sequel. There are many twisted and convoluted plot lines, and the web being spun around Natch is drawn ever tighter. As a good second book in a trilogy should do, it leaves us on a cliffhanger, wondering at the success or failure of its heroes.”

John is also the second reviewer to suggest that Edelman beats middle-book-of-a-trilogy syndrome, as he says, ” This is one of those rare cases (like The Empire Strikes Back vs. A New Hope) where the second movie far surpasses the first in quality and level of enjoyment. Fans of stories that mix philosophy and ethics, with action and technology will enjoy Edelman’s works.”

And who can balk at the final sentiment here: “It is a Matrix fans’ delight, and a worthy successor to Orson Scott Card’s Ender’s Game. I highly recommend Edelman as an author, and suggest you read Infoquake and its sequel MultiReal if you are looking for high-octane action, deep thinking, and eloquent writing.

MultiReal: A Matrix fans delight! Read More »

Red Alert: Starship Mutiny the Audiobook

Check it. Over on SFFAudio, the first review of a Pyr book’s audio edition! Yup, audio edition. Mike Resnick’s Starship Mutiny is out in audio from Audible.com. I’ve heard about 3 minutes and was very impressed with the quality. We didn’t actually have anything to do with this – it was a deal directly between Mike and Audible, but I’m happy to see it happen, and a big believer that a great audio book can inspire someone to go back and buy the “archival quality” hardcover (as I did with Neil Gaiman’s Coraline and Stephen King’s The Gunslinger both, for example.) Meanwhile, SFFAudio says:

“I can’t say that Resnick’s broken any new ground, but what he does is bring an immediacy and intelligence to the Military SF sub-genre. …all the gravitas of his intellectual legacy informs the action. It’s as if SF’s own Tolstoy were writing Horatio Hornblower by way of The Odyssey….The whole novel took me less than 36 hours to consume, its highly addictive listening and I confess I was downloading the follow-up book before I’d even finished this one. For a novel so light in ideas, the heart of SF, it’s hard to call it ‘unmissable,’ but on the other hand it masterfully achieves precisely what it intends to; it’s intelligent and entertaining Military SF – and that is still no small feat. Starship: Mutiny: Highly recommended!”

Red Alert: Starship Mutiny the Audiobook Read More »

A World Too Near, A Book Impossible to Put Down

Pat’s Fantasy Hotlist has a great interview with Kay Kenyon up today, apparently co-conducted by Patrick and SFFWorld’s Rob H. Bedford. Check it all out, but I particularly like Kay’s answer to the question of whether there were any “perceived conventions of the science fiction/fantasy genre” that she set out to “twist or break.” Kay replies:

“Well, first off, I wanted to celebrate some of the traditions, and make the story an unabashed fantasy quest. Insofar as the story has science fiction underpinnings, I did twist the usual space opera protagonist, making Titus Quinn deeply divided in his loyalties. Through the eyes of his daughter, Sydney, we get an unsparing view of Titus. Her deeply ambivalent feelings for Titus highlight his dilemmas and explore the question of how it’s possible to do good when all actions will create suffering. I wanted to turn a Flash Gordon concept into the thinking reader’s adventure novel. …As the story proceeded, I wanted to create fault lines in the reader’s assumptions about the Tarig overlords, who by tradition we want to despise. A pervasive goal was to give each character their value as a sentient being. This emphasis on character is also, in my view, a departure from the classic adventure tale.”

Meanwhile, earlier this week, Rob H. Bedford posted the SFFWorld review of the second book in Kay’s The Entire and the Rose series, A World Too Near, proclaiming that, “”Kenyon does a great job of maintaining the tension of this throughout the novel. “

[Spoiler Alert] If Bright of the Skywas Titus Quinn’s book, then this one is Joanna Quinn’s, as Rob observes, “While Titus is indeed the main character, Kenyon also shows his wife’s life in the Entire. In fact, the novel opens with a scene of Joanna Quinn, illustrating the grandeur of the Entire while juxtaposing it against the desperation Joanna feels in an otherwise beautiful place. Joanna’s scenes proved even more emotionally charged than those featuring Titus, there is a great deal of conflict within her and at times, she seems resigned to her fate and has given up hope of a return to the life she knew. While Joanna’s scenes aren’t as frequent as Titus’s, they are as powerful.”

Rob concludes that, “ultimately, I found myself unable to stop reading. As the novel draws to a close, the pressure builds for Titus and for Joanna, making for a briskly paced conclusion that you want to read through fast, but conversely, you don’t want to end. A tease at the end gives readers just enough to crave the next volume.”

Which is perfect, ennit?

A World Too Near, A Book Impossible to Put Down Read More »

Daughter of the Empire

Tomas L. Martin has reviewed Theodore Judson’s The Martian General’s Daughterfor SFCrowsnest with the intriguing description that it is “worthy sequel in spirit to The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire.”Which it is, as the book serves, as he says, as a”a strong, dynamic analysis of what happens when a nation grows too far and collapses under the pressure of its ambition.” And there is a large part of the narrative that is a retelling of the history of Marcus Aurelius and his son Commodius (who will be somewhat familiar to fans of the film Gladiator,yes), only that all this history is seen through the person of Justa, the daughter of the title. To me, her voice and her personal story are more powerful than the history she witnesses, which while it has a lot to say about the fall of empire (and, I believe, our own recent efforts at empire-building), is a vehicle for a very personal look at family. My two cents.

Update: Ah, and here comes a review on Neth Space that is the third one to use that word “compelling”when referring to Justa. They echo a little of what I’m talking about when they say, “The story gains new dimensions as it moves forward – becoming as much the story of Justa as the general. We slowly learn bits and pieces of Justa’s past as she relates the story of her father. As an empire decays, we feel that Justa thrives and grows. In the end, we have three stories in one – the death of empire, the biography of a great general, and the growth a young woman.”

Update 4/17/08: Jeff Vandermeer opines at Amazon’s Omnivoracious blog that, “this slim but satisfying novel is often willfully didactic in the way it treats political/military issues–but it works because of the context. These are the issues the characters are dealing with, this is the way they would talk about them. It’s rare that a book will make you think and make you feel in quite this particular way.”

Daughter of the Empire Read More »

Infoquake: Science Fiction’s John Grisham

There’s a new review of David Louis Edelman’s Infoquakeup on Grasping for the Wind, which proclaims “What John Grisham has done with the legal thriller, Edelman has done with business.” They describe Infoquake as “an adventure filled narrative,” and conclude, “Infoquake is well-written and well-cadenced. The climax is fulfilling and exciting, yet it is only a speech, and a marketing one at that. Edelman has so well woven the elements of his plot together that Natch’s simple speech has a much power and excitement to it as another science fiction story’s destruction of a spaceship or a fantasy’s evil overlord dying hideously at the hands of a hero. That takes skill to write, and Edelman has it in spades. I highly recommend this novel.”

Infoquake: Science Fiction’s John Grisham Read More »

Starlog on Killswitch: Tight and Crackling!

Starlog on Killswitch:

“Shepherd continues to improve with each installment. Readers who have been wanting a far more intense story will find themselves amply rewarded as Shepherd puts his remarkable heroine through her paces. As with the previous novels, there are shifts between a great many characters also vying for attention, but the writing here is tight and crackling and turns the entire trilogy into an excellent adventure, with the spotlight clearly on Cassandra.”

Starlog on Killswitch: Tight and Crackling! Read More »

Brasyl works for Brazilians!

Jacques Barcia has posted a review of Brasylat Human 2.0. “McDonald was able to capture, with amazing precision, th Brazilian spirit. And he did this without clichés, without hullabaloos, but with critical observations regarding the importance Brazilian people gives to beauty, soccer and TV. Besides, geographically everything is right and linguistically, it is better than most foreigners trying the language of Camões.”

The conclusion: Despite a great deal of Portuguese mispellngs, Brasyl is “A hell of an accomplishment for a gringo, definitely Brasyl is a book Brazilians must read.”

Brasyl works for Brazilians! Read More »

Scroll to Top